‘A Conversation with Black America’
Dear CNN,
I don’t watch you by choice. I watch you when you’re on that TV in Annenberg Hall when I’m eating lunch and it’s an easy way to know what’s going on.
But today I am seriously disgusted by you. More than usual.
See, your ‘Conversation with Black America’ isn’t helping. It’s setting up black America as something different from the rest of America that you normally cover. It’s exoticising a whole group of people. I mean, for chrissakes, you had a survey asking ‘black America’ which issues they were concerned with. Guess what, number one was still the economy, followed by the war in Iraq, education, and all the same issues the rest of Americans are concerned with.
Stop patting yourself on the back because you’re broadcasting from the “nation’s first black radio station” (which gives the impression that the first black radio station is a recent thing). And for Martin Luther King’s own sake, stop giving John McCain a platform to offend all those of us who remember that he voted against the MLK holiday and voted against King’s civil rights bills. John McCain does not give a rat’s ass about Martin Luther King.
Hillary Clinton is only slightly less offensive, considering that her argument to superdelegates is basically that the people who support her won’t vote for Obama, which is a thinly veiled reference to the fact that she’s pulling the racist vote.
And maybe that’s why John McCain is pandering, CNN, in case Hillary does manage to win. In any case, you should know better.
But maybe if you’d followed the recommendations of the Kerner Commission from 40 years ago and actually hired more than a token black reporter here and there, you’d know better. You wouldn’t feel the need to have a ‘conversation with black America’ because you’d have one every day, like I do.
See, black America is not different from my America. It is my students and my professors, my friends (and maybe more than friends), my neighbors, the people I talk to every day, and they want the same things that I want.
They certainly don’t need your condescending to have a ‘conversation’ with them one day out of the year. And why this year? Because it’s the 40th anniversary of King’s death, or because we have a black man who’s the front-runner for the Democratic presidential nomination?
Talk to black people about issues that aren’t just “black” issues. Talk to women about issues that aren’t just women’s issues. Stop reducing the presidential race to a pile of demographics and actually go out and report on what the candidates are talking about and what they’ve done in the past.
You’d learn a lot.
-Sarah
PS: Go here and watch the Mountaintop speech. Or I’ve got audio of it here.
Posted: April 4th, 2008 under Bullshit, Media.
Comments: 2
Comments
Comment from a.eye
Time: April 5, 2008, 3:11 am
Nice post.
Are you saying that you want the media to actually pay attention to what the candidates say and what they imply with their actions? That would make way too much sense and would cause viewers to actually understand the candidates’ stances on different topics. If that happened they would likely lose the majority of their supporters and then the election might actually go in a way that would support the country’s interests. And that would just be horrible. Instead, the media must just use mostly sound-bites and allow the candidates to try and apologize for their actions/inactions so that people can continue to support them.
Comment from Alex Hepler
Time: April 11, 2008, 10:41 pm
Dividing people into groups-
If either of our major political parties makes a statement similar to: “We are working to reach out to black (or female or Latino, etc.) voters”, why doesn’t anyone come forward and say: “Wait a second, just because a person has any particular skin color, or is a man or a woman- that does not mean that they all think, act, behave and vote in the same manner”?
It’s 2008- do not judge people by the color of their skin- unless you work on strategy for one of our major political parties.
Alex
Port Hadlock, WA


Write a comment