sex. politics. rock’n'roll. film. comics. lipgloss. monsters.

Endorsements

Twitter

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Tags

Awards


This blog was rated E for Excellent by Macon D of Stuff white people do.


Award from Caroline of UnCool

Archive

Meta

Slut.

Part 2 in the sex series.

Please read this first: why anti-sex work feminism is objectifying.

Now, for the S-word.

That word hits me like a slap across the face–it leaves marks. And it’s so totally unexpected when it does happen, now that I’m not in high school or even college. When it slips out of the mouth of a male friend–not directed at me or a real person–I shudder before calmly and patiently explaining that I wasn’t OK with that word in ANY context, I didn’t care how much I disliked the girl in question. That it’s a word that hurts me as much as any woman it’s directed at.

My ex used to use the word a lot and I honestly can’t believe now that I stayed with him as long as I did, because it should’ve shown me that he thought women’s sexuality needed to be controlled. And that I should’ve known it would come back on me, because there are no good girls and bad girls, there are just girls and they are all me. Every time we try to delineate boundaries between the girls that do the right things and the girls that do the wrong things, we’re just trying to make excuses for why bad things happened to them but can’t happen to us. And that’s just wrong. And when my ex called some girl a slut I would refuse to talk to him until he apologized, but it kept coming back, that return of the repressed, because the attitude inside wasn’t changing, he just wanted to appease me.

I’ve successfully reclaimed bitch. You can call me a bitch all day and I’ll laugh at you, admit it with pride. Other people, not so much–I’ll still bristle and tell you to stop if you call Hillary Clinton a bitch in front of me (although see last post for reasons I’m not feeling too bad for her lately)

But slut still stings worse. Even in situations where the woman wears it as a badge of honor, I’m still uncomfortable with it. I cannot see it that way.

Maybe because slut is the one most often used by women against other women (along with ‘fat’). Women used slut to wound and to mark others as inappropriate, as socially unacceptable, as vicious–a slut will take your man, she doesn’t care, in fact she likes it. She doesn’t deserve female friends, she’s not loyal to women, she just cares about male attention. Slut doesn’t even mean you have lots of sex or even any sex–it just means you look like you might, or talk like you might.

The slut is a monster. Her body is the body of all women (”a cultural body”). She doesn’t recognize boundaries (”harbinger of category crisis”) and she is not like you (”dwells at the gates of difference”). She is what you should not be, she defines by being it what is wrong (”polices the borders of the possible”) and yet, strangely, she makes you jealous. You want to be her. (”Fear of the monster is really a kind of desire.”) Most importantly:

“They [monsters] ask us to reevaluate our cultural assumptions about race, gender, sexuality, our perception of difference, our tolerance toward its expression. They ask us why we have created them.”

My college roommate gave me the craziest look when I told her that I was going to a fetish party the night before Halloween. Despite the fact that at the time, I’d never even had sex. But I’d made myself appear sexual and I’d talked about sex, out loud. That was enough.

(I almost felt the need to justify myself further here by talking about said roommate’s sexual behavior, which shows you how deeply this shit is ingrained–it’s certainly not right for me to pass judgment on her sex life any more than it was for her to do it to me. Hell, it’s stupid that I justified myself by pointing out that I was a virgin.)

But the point is that when a woman publicly appears to be sexual, declares herself sexual, we try to shove her back into that box.

There’ll be another post in this series about ‘virginity’ so I’m not going there right now.

What I am going to talk about instead is feminist slut-shaming.

See, the anti-porn types love to do this and disguise it as concern for all women. Kind of the way your friends would pull you aside in high school and tell you that “I didn’t say it, but this other girl over there said you were a SLUT so you better watch it.”

That’s just not okay.

Sex workers get it the worst, of course. They’re pornified. They’re penis accessories and will soon be used-up-has-beens. They’re fucked up and in denial and playing Russian Roulette. (thanks to Ren for those links, and if you aren’t reading her yet, why the hell not?)

But it’s not just sex workers. It’s all of us who don’t keep our unruly desires in check. It’s any of us who don’t make excuses for men’s bad behavior and wear what we want to wear. Hell, it’s any of us who don’t hate men, it seems sometimes.

See, me? I’m middle of the road. I’m average size, white, middle-class straight girl. Jewish, tatttooed, overeducated, little bit kinky but mostly I’d fit the definition of ordinary. I wouldn’t come in for slut-shaming at all (and haven’t yet on the blogosphere) if I didn’t choose to associate myself with the pro-sex crowd. Did some writing for Suicide Girls. Intern at BUST. Read Ren and Melissa Gira and Amber Rhea and of course Susie Bright, and many, many others. Which means, according to some, that I can’t be a proper feminist.

I don’t watch a lot of porn, but I will damn well defend your right to do so, and to be in it.

See, my best friends have been strippers for a while. And I don’t mean that in a “I can’t be racist, I have black friends!” kind of way, but in a way that makes it different from being an “ally” (also see Ren on the subject). It means being a person that actually personally loves and cares about people who work in these industries, treats them as people, not as research subjects, and doesn’t fucking dare to speak for them when they are big girls who can speak for themselves.

And their unruly sexuality doesn’t fit in your box. And if it did, it doesn’t belong there. And neither does mine.

Because I’ll talk about it here with my real name up there for everyone to see. Because I realized that my fear of talking about sex was really just another form of slut-shaming. See, I don’t have moral compunction about actual sex. I could honestly give a fuck about social conventions on what I like and dislike and who I like. And I’ve discovered that yeah, my tastes may be normal, but I’ve given myself the freedom to figure it out and to make myself happy along the way.

See, you can have sex, most radfems say. You just can’t talk about it. You can’t openly signify that you are sexual and oh god you certainly can’t signify that you LIKE it, especially if it’s with men. And you certainly can’t make any MONEY off of it, trade on it the way we have to trade on all bits of ourselves in this fucked-up system.

I’m deeply sorry that my orgasms don’t fit your plans for the revolution. Just let me keep a couple of boys around after we dispose of the men, Queen of the Damned style. Until then, though, I have to live in the world I’m in, and sometimes I choose to walk through it in heels and short skirts, and sometimes I choose to flirt with men, and sometimes I choose to actually date and sleep with men, and sometimes I like to read about sex. And I don’t need anyone’s permission to do it–and that IS feminist, thanks.

Just as I don’t need permission from a man to be sexual or not, I don’t need permission from women, either. I thank feminism for teaching me that, and for teaching me to center my own desires, not those of men. So even if they happen to coincide, that doesn’t mean I’m doing it FOR THEM. I’m a big girl, and I do what  makes me happy.

And I’m going to keep right on talking about it.

Comments

Comment from belledame222
Time: May 24, 2008, 3:52 pm

>>And I don’t mean that in a “I can’t be racist, I have black friends!” kind of way, but in a way that makes it different from being an “ally” (also see Ren on the subject). It means being a person that actually personally loves and cares about people who work in these industries, treats them as people, not as research subjects, and doesn’t fucking dare to speak for them when they are big girls who can speak for themselves.>>

Yeah. That.

Comment from Purtek
Time: May 26, 2008, 1:44 am

Ditto to belledame’s ditto.

Re: slut. I’ve struggled with that one in a “reclaiming” sense, as well, and I agree with this:

But slut still stings worse. Even in situations where the woman wears it as a badge of honor, I’m still uncomfortable with it.

In contrast to “bitch”, there’s something much more dehumanizing in the connotation to the word “slut”. Being called a “bitch” means I’m pissing people off; being called a “slut” generally makes me aware that the person who said it has just dismissed my worth completely. Personally, I would *really* like to be able to “reclaim” it for exactly that reason, but I’m iffy on the concept of “reclaiming” slurs/insults anyway.

Comment from Renee
Time: May 26, 2008, 3:08 am

Some words are simply beyond reclamation. Slut just like the word nigger has history of hatred, dismissal and exploitation. You cannot change the meaning no matter how hard you try. If it cannot be said by everyone and interpreted as a positive thing, then it should be locked away in a “word vault” and never uttered again. Regardless of who uses the word slut what they are trying to do is express some of power through demeaning someone. It can never be used in solidarity.

Comment from RenegadeEvolution
Time: May 26, 2008, 4:14 am

slut so pales in my mind as an insult…but yep, one women have used for years to keep each other in check

Comment from whatsername
Time: May 26, 2008, 4:54 am

Right on.

I don’t particularly have an issue with “slut” reclaiming. But in becoming more aware of the way the word is used…I can see why it gets to you so much.

Comment from feministgal
Time: May 26, 2008, 7:26 pm

I wrote a really long reaction/comment to this post but i’m on a bus, the wifi is spotty, and said comment got erased. Because it’s never as good the second time all i’ll say is that this post was the best thing i’ve read all month. you hit the nail on the head (for me) again and again in so many ways.

You beautifully wrote,”And that I should’ve known it would come back on me, because there are no good girls and bad girls, there are just girls and they are all me.”

This is so unbelievably true and i’ve never thought about it at all. So many things you wrote in this post were such light bulbs for me and even though i’ve always agreed with everything you said, i’ve never thought it through with words, always a general understanding/thought - you verbalized it exceptionally, thank you for that. This post is brilliant, beautiful, and honest in so many ways.

Comment from Lady S
Time: May 27, 2008, 5:48 pm

I get what you mean about slut. For me it’s quite a hurtful thing as it’s been used against me by my family. I’d love to claim it back - but it essentially says ‘you are bad for having/liking sex. You are worthless because of that’

It invokes a whole shitload of history and stereotypes down on one person’s head - even if you don’t buy into them it hurts that people can reduce you in that way.

One of the hardest things to me, in reading a lot of online feminisms at first was it took a while to find people who would actually be proud of their sexuality, rather than merely just ‘tolerant’ of the fact it was there.

Feminisms, in my opinion, should centre on how you can live with yourself and help other women accept and enjoy their lives (and that means working to remove things that DO oppress women such as attitudes and laws) not just stuff them in boxes for the revolutions sake.

Sorry for the rant!

Comment from belledame222
Time: May 27, 2008, 9:15 pm

For me, “slut” has no real personal impact, or not much, since I was never hit with that one. I was the nerd, the geek, the good girl, the wallflower–and of course the closet dyke/lez, (those latter had a lot more impact). I was dimly aware of a couple of girls in high school and junior high who had the “slut” reputation, one in particular, and of course I knew what it meant, but…maybe I just sensed that it was one more way of making so and so an “untouchable,” that they particularly made jokes in musical theatre class about how skanky she was, how easy it was for her to do the splits or whatever it was. I guess I didn’t have a clear idea of why she was a “slut” and all the other girls who I was pretty damn sure were also having sex weren’t. In retrospect, I expect it had to do with her (I believe) either being or being perceived as being from the wrong side of the tracks, you know: loud, tacky…something, she didn’t “fit,” that much I tweaked.

Comment from Alexa
Time: May 27, 2008, 11:11 pm

That word hits me like a slap across the face–it leaves marks. And it’s so totally unexpected when it does happen, now that I’m not in high school or even college. When it slips out of the mouth of a male friend–not directed at me or a real person–I shudder before calmly and patiently explaining that I wasn’t OK with that word in ANY context, I didn’t care how much I disliked the girl in question. That it’s a word that hurts me as much as any woman it’s directed at.

I have reclaimed the word “slut” with respect to it being used with me, and even embrace it. However, I am like you in that, when I hear it used against someone else, I want to go ape shit on whoever used it (and have been known to).

Comment from EKSwitaj
Time: June 1, 2008, 5:52 am

The man who raped me used the word slut to denigrate me. Not bitch, not cunt, not any other of the myriad words that have been used to shame and defame women. Slut.

He was jealous of that “monstrous” sexual aspect of myself not for the reasons women might be but for the fact that he could not wholly possess it.

So slut-shaming in the name of feminism is incredibly offensive to me.

Write a comment